Volume 7 (2024)

First page of the paper.


Cases of Oral Pathologies from the First Archaeological Survey of Nubia

Forshaw, Roger

Abstract:

This study investigates three cases of oral pathology identified in skeletal and mummified remains originally excavated during the First Archaeological Survey of Nubia (1907-1911). While the Survey Team conducted an extensive analysis and published their initial findings in the first year of the Project, subsequent results were minimally documented. These remains have now been re–examined, as part of the Grafton Elliot Smith Project. The first of the cases involves a significant pathological bony cavity in the maxilla attributed to an odontogenic infection that caused perforation of the maxillary sinus. Evidence of chronic sinusitis on the in¬ner sinus wall suggests the infection persisted during the individual’s life. The second one presents features consistent with leprosy, including the distinctive rhinomaxillary syndrome, characterised by perforation of the hard palate and resorption of the alveolar bone supporting the maxillary anterior teeth. The final case fo¬cuses on a bilateral cleft palate found in an adult skull and considers the implications of survival into adult¬hood with this condition in an ancient societal context. These pathologies have been reassessed in the framework of recent research and discoveries made over the past century.

Citation:

Forshaw, R. 2024. «Cases of Oral Pathologies from the First Archaeological Survey of Nubia», JHIE 7: 85–96

DOI:

10.5281/zenodo.15301525

Language: en

Submitted on 2024-08-02; accepted on 2024-11-20

References

  • Alt, K.W., Türp, J.C. & Wächter, R.: «Periapical Lesions – Clinical and Anthropological Aspects», Dental Anthropology (Alt, K.W., Rösing, F.W. & Teschler–Nicola, M., eds), Vienna (Springer) 1998, 247-276.
  • Anderson, : «Medieval Example of Cleft Lip and Palate from St. Gregory’s Priory, Canterbury», Cleft Palate–Craniofacial Journal 316, 1994, 466-472.
  • Anderson, G. & Manchester, K.: «The Rhinomaxillary Syndrome in Leprosy: A Clinical, Radiological and Palaeopathological Study», International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 22, 1992, 121-129.
  • Aufderheide, C. & Rodríguez–Martin, C.: The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Human Paleopathology, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 1998.
  • Becker de Oliveira, L., Fonseca–Souza, G., Rolim, T.Z.C., Scariot, R. & Feltrin–Souza, J.: «Breastfeeding and Cleft Lip and Palate: A Systematic Review and Meta–Analysis», The Cleft Palate Craniofacial Journal 618, 2024, 1344-55.
  • Bhattacharya, S., Khanna, V. & Kohli, R.: «Cleft Lip: The Historical Perspective», Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery 42 (Supplement), 2009, 4-8.
  • Boocock, P., Roberts, C.A. & Manchester, K.: «Maxillary Sinusitis in Medieval Chichester, England», American Journal of Physical Anthropology 984, 1995, 483-495.
  • Brand, P.W.: «Temperature Variation and Leprosy», International Journal of Leprosy 271, 1959, 1-7.
  • Brooks, S.T. & Hohenthal, W.D.: «Archaeological Defective Palate Crania from California», American Journal of Physical Anthropology 211, 1963, 25-32.
  • Browne, R.M.: «Some Observations of the Fluid of Odontogenic Cysts», Journal of Oral Pathology 52, 1976, 74-87.
  • Clarke, H. J.: «Toothaches and Death», Journal of the History of Dentistry 47, 1999, 11-13.
  • Clarren, S.K., Anderson, B. & Wolf, L.S.: «Feeding Infants with Cleft Lip, Cleft Palate, or Cleft Lip and Palate», Cleft Palate Journal 243, 1987, 244-49.
  • Cockitt, J., Harris, M., Metcalfe, R., Forshaw, R., MacLeod, N. & David, R.: «Capturing a Century of Study: The Search for the Human Remains from The First Archaeological Survey Of Nubia (1907-1911)», Antiquity Project Gallery 86 (332) 2012 [URL: http://antiquity.ac.uk/projgall/cockitt332 ].
  • Cook, D.C.: «Rhinomaxillary Syndrome in the Absence of Leprosy: An Exercise in Differential Diagnosis», The Past and Present of Leprosy: Archaeological, Historical, Palaeopathological and Clinical Approaches (Roberts, A., Lewis, M.E. & Manchester, K., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress / BAR Series 1054) 2002, 81-88.
  • Deps, P., do Espírito Santo, R.B., Charlier, P. & Collin, S.M.: «Rhinomaxillary Syndrome in Hansen’s Disease: A Clinical Perspective», International Journal of Dermatology 5911, 2020, e404-e406 [DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/microbiolspec ].
  • Derry, D.E.: The Archaeological Survey of Nubia: Bulletin № 3, Cairo (Ministry of Finance, Survey Department) 1909.
  • Derry, D.E.: «Two Skulls with Absence of the Premaxilla», Journal of Anatomy 722, 1938, 295-298.
  • Dettwyler, K.A.: «Can Paleopathology Provide Evidence for “Compassion”?», American Journal of Physical Anthropology 844, 1991, 375-384.
  • Dias, G.T. & Tayles, N.: «“Abscess Cavity” – A Misnomer», International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 75, 1997, 548-554.
  • Dzierzykray–Rogalski, : «Paleopathology of the Ptolemaic Inhabitants of Dakhleh Oasis (Egypt)», Journal of Human Evolution 91, 1980, 71-74.
  • Fehrenbach, M.J. & Herring, S.W.: «Spread of Dental Infection», Practical Hygiene /Oct. 1997, 1997, 13-19.
  • Forshaw, R.J.: «Dental Health and Disease in Ancient Egypt», British Dental Journal 206, 2009, 421-428.
  • Forshaw, R.J.: «Dental Infections in Ancient Nubia», Palaeopathology in Egypt and Nubia: A Century in Review (Metcalfe, R., Cockitt, J. & David, R., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress / Archaeopress Egyptology 6) 2014, 69-81.
  • Galler, K.M., Weber, M., Korkmaz, Y., Widbiller, M. & Feuerer M.: «Inflammatory Response Mechanisms of the Dentine–Pulp Complex and the Periapical Tissues», International Journal of Molecular Sciences 223, 2021, 1480.
  • Gamza, T.I. & Irish, J.: «A Comparison of Archaeological and Dental Evidence to Determine Diet at a Predynastic Egyptian Site», International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 224, 2010, 398-408.
  • Gladykowska–Rzeczycka, J.: «Congenital Abnormalities of Early Polish Man», Advances in Paleopathology (Journal of Paleopathology Monograph Publications № 1) (Carpasso, L., ed.), Chieti (Marino Solfanelli) 1989, 111-116.
  • Hanson, J.W. & Murray, J.C.: «Genetic Aspects of Cleft Lip and Palate», Multidisciplinary Management of Cleft Lip and Palate (Bardach, J. & Morris, H.L., eds) Philadelphia (W. B. Saunders) 1990, 121-124.
  • Hess, & Rambukkana, A.: «Cell Biology of Intracellular Adaptation of Mycobacterium leprae in the Peripheral Nervous System», Microbiology Spectrum 74, 2019 [DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/microbiolspec.bai-0020-2019 ].
  • Hillson, S.: Dental Anthropology, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 2
  • Hoffman, H. & Hudgins, P.A.: «Head and Skull Base Features of Nine Egyptian Mummies: Evaluation with High–Resolution CT and Reformation Techniques», American Journal of Roentgenology 1786, 2002, 1367-1376.
  • Igoumenakis, , Gkinis, G., Kostakis, G., Mezitis, M. & Rallis, G.: «Severe Odontogenic Infections: Causes of Spread and their Management», Surgical Infections 151, 2014, 64-68.
  • Lee, M.J., Siek, T.J., & Hirst, C. S.: «Chronic Maxillary Sinusitis in Palaeopathology: A Review of Methods», International Journal of Paleopathology 44, 2024, 51-64.
  • Manchester, K.: «Infective Bone Changes in Leprosy», The Past and Present of Leprosy: Archaeological, Historical, Palaeopathological and Clinical Approaches (Roberts, C.A., Lewis, M.E. & Manchester, K., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress / BAR Series 1054) 2002, 69-72.
  • Metcalfe, J.: The Archaeological Survey of Nubia Season 2 (1908-1909): Report on the Human Remains, Oxford (Archaeopress / Access Archaeology) 2024.
  • Michaïlidis,, Kyriazi, S., Maravelia, A., Tourna, E., Couvaris, C.M., Kalampoukas, K., Pantazis, I., Lazaris, P., Geroulanos, S., Kalogerakou, K. & Bontozoglou, N.: «Chronic Maxillary Atelectasis under the Wrappings of an Egyptian Mummy», Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology 12812, 2019, 1165-1169 [DOI: 10.1177/0003489419879716].
  • Michman, & Sagher, F.: «Changes in the Anterior Nasal Spine and the Alveolar Process of the Maxillary Bone in Leprosy», International Journal of Leprosy 253, 1957, 217-222.
  • Møller–Christensen, V.: Bone Changes in Leprosy, Copenhagen (Munksgaard) 1961.
  • Møller–Christensen, V.: Leprosy Changes of the Skull, Odense (Odense University Press) 1978.
  • Møller–Christensen, V. & Hughes, D.R.: «An Early Case of Leprosy», Man, New Series 12, 1966, 242-243.
  • Molto, J.E.: «Leprosy in Roman Period Skeletons from Kellis 2, Dakhleh, Egypt», The Past and Present of Leprosy: Archaeological, Historical, Palaeopathological and Clinical Approaches (Roberts, C.A., Lewis, M.E. & Manchester, K., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress / BAR Series 1054) 2002, 179-192.
  • Nagase, Y., Natsume, N., Kato, T. & Hayakawa, T.: «Epidemiological Analysis of Cleft Lip and/or Palate by Cleft Pattern», Journal of Maxillofacial and Oral Surgery 94, 2010, 389-395.
  • Nair, P.N.R.: «Pathogenesis of Apical Periodontitis and the Causes of Endodontic Failures», Critical Reviews in Oral Biology and Medicine 156, 2004, 348-381.
  • Odell, E.W.: Cawson’s Essentials of Oral Pathology and Oral Medicine, Edinburgh–London–Oxford (Elsevier Health Services) 10
  • Ortner, D.J.: «Observations on the Pathogenesis of Skeletal Disease in Leprosy», The Past and Present of Leprosy: Archaeological, Historical, Palaeopathological and Clinical Approaches (Roberts, C.A., Lewis, M.E. & Manchester, K., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress / BAR Series 1054) 2002, 73-80.
  • Roberts, C. & Manchester, K.: The Archaeology of Disease, Cheltenham (The History Press) 3
  • Rodrigues, G.A, Qualio, N.P., de Macedo, L.D., Innocentini, L.M.A.R., Ribeiro–Silva, A., Foss, N.T., Frade, M. A. C. & Motta, A.C.F.: «The Oral Cavity in Leprosy: What Clinicians need to know», Oral Diseases 236, 2017, 749-756.
  • Salari, , Darvishi, N., Heydari, M., Bokaee, S., Darvishi, F. & Mohammadi, M.: «Global Prevalence of Cleft Palate, Cleft Lip and Cleft Palate and Lip: A Comprehensive Systematic Review and Meta–Analysis», Journal of Stomatology Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 1232, 2022, 110-120.
  • Smith, G.E. & Jones, F.W.: The Archaeological Survey of Nubia, Report for 1907-1908. Volume II: Report on the Human Remains, Cairo (National Printing Department) 1910.
  • Stone, A.C., Wilbur, A.K., Buikstra, J.E. & Roberts, C.A.: «Tuberculosis and Leprosy in Perspective», American Journal of Physical Anthropology 140 ( 49), 2009, 66-94.
  • Subramanian, K., Marks, S.C. & Nah, S.H.: «The Rate of Loss of Maxillary Anterior Bone Height in Patients with Leprosy», Leprosy Review 54, 1983, 119-127.
  • Tilley, L.: Theory and Practice in the Bioarchaeology of Care, Switzerland (Springer International Publishing) 2015.
  • Tolarová, M.: «Genetic Findings in Cleft Lip and Palate», Multidisciplinary Management of Cleft Lip and Palate (Bardach, J. & Morris, H.L., eds) Philadelphia (W.B. Saunders) 1990, 113-121.
  • Uluibau, I.C., Jaunay, T. & Goss, A.N.: «Severe Odontogenic Infections», Australian Dental Journal Medications Supplement 504, 2005, 74-81.
  • Vanderas, A.P.: «Incidence of Cleft Lip, Cleft Palate and Cleft Lip and Palate among Races: A Review», Cleft Palate Journal 243, 1987, 216-225.
More papers from this issue