Volume 7 (2024)

First page of the paper.

Comparison between the Astronomical Ceilings of the Pharaonic and the Ptolemaic Era

Salamida, Barbara

Abstract:

This paper examines the evolution of Egyptian astronomical ceilings from the Pharaonic Period down to the Ptolemaic Era, with a particular focus on how these ceilings may reflect the changing cosmovisional views of the ancient Egyptians. The introduction provides an overview of the importance of Astronomy in ancient Egyptian culture, linking it to both: religious practices and daily life. The main body of the article presents a comparative analysis of astronomical ceilings found in tombs of the New Kingdom (c. 1550-1069 BC), such as the Tomb of Son–en–Mut, and temples from the Ptolemaic Period (332-30 BC). By focusing on key elements, such as the introduction of the Zodiac, the representations of Winds, the adaptation of decanal stars, and the integration of planetary deities, this study examines how Ptolemaic astronomical ceilings selectively incorporated foreign influences while maintaining core Egyptian traditions. This shift was not merely decorative but signaled a deeper integration of foreign astronomical traditions into Egyptian thought. This illustrates how Egyptian astronomical traditions absorbed and adapted external influences, showcasing the dynamic exchange of knowledge and astronomical lore between Egypt and other antique cultures.

Citation:

Salamida, B. 2024. «Comparison between the Astronomical Ceilings of the Pharaonic and the Ptolemaic Era», JHIE 7: 45–62

DOI:

10.5281/zenodo.15301495

Language: en

Submitted on 2024-03-06; accepted on 2024-12-27

References

  • Altmann–Wendling, V.: MondSymbolik–MondWissen: Lunare Konzepte in den agyptischen Tempeln griechisch–romischer Zeit I-II, Wiesbaden (Harrassowitz Verlag / Studien zur spatagyptischen Religion 22) 2018.
  • Belmonte, –A.: «The Decans and the Ancient Egyptian Skylore: An Astronomer’s Approach», Memorie della Societa Astronomica Italiana 731, 2002, 43-57.
  • Belmonte, J.–A.: «The Ramesside Star Clocks and the Egyptian Constellations», Calendars, Symbols and Orientations: Proceedings of the 9th Meeting of the SEAC, Stockholm 27-30 August 2001 (Blomberg, et al., eds), Uppsala (Uppsala Astronomical Observatory / Report 59) 2003, 57-65.
  • Belmonte, J.–A. & Lull, : Astronomy of Ancient Egypt: A Cultural Perspective (Orchiston, W. et al., eds), Cham, Switzerland (Springer–Verlag / Historical & Cultural Astronomy Series) 12023.
  • Belmonte, J.–A. & Shaltout, M.A.M.: «The Astronomical Ceiling of Senenmut: A Dream of Mystery and Imagination», Lights and Shadows in Cultural Astronomy: Proceedings of the SEAC 2005, Isili, Sardinia, 28 June to 3 July (Belmonte, J.–A. & Zedda, M.–P., eds), Isili (Comune di Isili – IAC) 2007, 145-154.
  • Belmonte, J.–A. & Shaltout, M.A.M. (eds): In Search of Cosmic Order: Selected Essays on Egyptian Archaeoastronomy, Cairo (SCA Press) 2009.
  • Bertozzi, E. & Ilari, V.: L’Astronomia Tolemaica e gli Strumenti Osservativi Descritti nell’Almagesto, Bologna (Universita di Bologna) 2019.
  • BMD = Shaw, I. & Nicholson, P. (eds): British Museum Dictionary of Ancient Egypt, London (AUC Press) 1995.
  • Cauville, S.: Le Zodiaque d’Osiris, Leuven (Peeters) 1997.
  • Clagett, M.: Ancient Egyptian Science: A Source Book II: Calendars, Clocks and Astronomy, Philadelphia (American Philosophical Society / Memoirs APS 214) 1995.
  • Depuydt, L.: Civil Calendar and Lunar Calendar in Ancient Egypt, Leeuwen (Uitgeverij Peeters / OLA 77) 1997.
  • Depuydt, L.: «Ancient Egyptian Star Clocks and their Theory», BiOr 551-2, 1998, 6-44.
  • Dorman, P.: The Monuments of Senenmut: Problems of Historical Methodology, London (Routledge) 1988.
  • Dorman, : The Tombs of Senenmut: The Architecture and Decoration of Tombs 71 and 353, New York (The Metropolitan Museum of New York) 1991.
  • EAT = Neugebauer, & Parker, R.A.: Egyptian Astronomical Texts, I: The Early Decans; II: The Ramesside Star Clocks; III: Decans, Planets, Constellations & Zodiacs / Plates, Providence RI (Brown University Press) 1960-1969.
  • EG = Gardiner, A.H.: Egyptian Grammar: Being an Introduction to the Study of Hieroglyphs, Oxford (Griffith Institute, Ashmolean Museum) 3
  • Frankfort, H.: The Cenotaph of Sethi I at Abydos I-II, London (Egypt Exploration Society / Memoirs 39) 1933.
  • Franci, M.: Astronomia egizia. Introduzione alle conoscenze astronomiche dell’antico Egitto, Firenze (Edarc Edizioni) 2010.
  • Franci, M.: «Defining Time», Liber Amicorum – Speculum Siderum: Nut Astrophoros: Papers Presented to Alicia Maravelia (Guilhou, N., ed.), Oxford (Archaeopress / Egyptology 17) 2016, 139-150.
  • Gautschy, R.: «Der Stern Sirius im Alten Agypten», ZAS 138, 2011, 116-131.
  • Guardiano, L.: Il Cielo dei Faraoni. I Soffitti Astronomici dell’Egitto del Nuovo Regno, Milano (Milano University Press) 2024.
  • Hannig, R.: Großes Handworterbuch Agyptisch–Deutsch (2800-950 v. Chr.), Mainz (P. von Zabern) 5
  • Hornung, E.: The Ancient Egyptian Books of the Afterlife (translated by Dr D. Lorton), Ithaca–London (Cornell University Press) 1999.
  • Kaper, O.E.: «The Astronomical Ceiling of Deir ᾿el-Haggar in the Dakhleh Oasis», JEA 811, 1995, 175-196.
  • LA = Helck, W. & Otto, E. (Hrsg.): Lexikon der Agyptologie I-VII, Wiesbaden (Harrassowitz Verlag) 1975-1989.
  • Leitz, C.: Studien zur agyptischen Astronomie, Wiesbaden (O. Harrassowitz / AgAbh 49) 11989 [21991].
  • Leitz, C.: «Le premier plafond astronomique dans la tombe de Senmout», Les Dossiers d’Archeologie 187, 1993, 116-117.
  • Leitz, C.: Scienza egizia. Astronomia e calendari, Roma (Treccani) 2001.
  • Maravelia,–A.: Les astres dans les textes religieux en Egypte antique et dans les Hymnes Orphiques, Oxford (Archaeopress/ BAR International Series 1527) 2006.
  • Maravelia, A.: «The Function and Importance of Some Special Categories of Stars in the Ancient Egyptian Funerary Texts, 1: AxAx– and iAd–Stars», Proceedings of the 11th International Congress of Egyptologists (Florence 23-30 August 2015) (Guidotti, M.–C. & Rosati, G., eds), Oxford (Archaeopress Egyptology 19) 2017, 368-376.
  • Maravelia, A.: «Astronomy in Ancient Egypt / Astronomia no Antigo Egipto», Hapi 6, Lisbon 2018a, 20-31.
  • Maravelia, A.: «Of Eternity, Everlastingness and Stars: Notions of Time, Space, Duration and the Firmament in the Pyramid and Coffin Texts», Time and Space at Issue in Ancient Egypt (Chantrain, G. & Winand, J., eds), Hamburg (Lingua Aegyptia / Studia Monographica 19), 2018b, 81-110.
  • Maravelia, A.–A. & Shaltout, M.A.M.: «The Great Temples of Thebes and the Sunrise in the Winter Solstice: Applying Modern Archaeoastronomical Techniques to study the Ancient Egyptian Mansions of Millions of Years», The Temples of Millions of Years and the Royal Power at Thebes in the New Kingdom: Science and New Technologies applied to Archaeology (Leblanc, C. & Zaki, G. eds), Memnonia: Cahier Supplementaire 2, Cairo 2011, 283-295 & Pl. LVII-LX.
  • Mendel, : Die Geographie des Himmels: Eine Untersuchung zu den Deckendekorationen in agyptischen Tempeln der griechisch–romischen Zeit u. zeitgleichen Darstellungen auf Sargen u. in Grabern I-II, Wiesbaden (Harrassowitz Verlag / SSR 37) 2022.
  • Museo Egizio: Museo Egizio, Torino (Einaudi) 2015.
  • Neugebauer, O.: Τhe Exact Sciences in Antiquity, Providence RI (Brown University Press) 2
  • Ossendrijver, M. & Winkler, A.: «Chaldeans on the Nile: Two Egyptian Astronomical Procedure Texts with Babylonian Systems A1 and A2 for Mercury», «The Scaffolding of our Thoughts»: Essays on Assyriology and the History of Science in Honor of Francesca Rochberg (Crisostomo, J.A., Escobar, E.A. et al., eds), Leiden (Brill) 2018, 382-419.
  • Parker, R.A.: The Calendars of Ancient Egypt, Chicago (University of Chicago / SAOC 26) 1950.
  • PM = Porter, B. & Moss, R.L.B. (with Burney, E.W.): Topographical Bibliography of Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphic Texts, Reliefs and Paintings I-VIII, Oxford (Oxford at the Clarendon Press | Griffith Institute, Asmolean Museum) 1939-
  • Pogo, A.: «The Astronomical Ceiling–Decoration in the Tomb of Senmut», Isis 142, 1930, 301-325 & Pl. 11-20.
  • Redford, D.B.: Akhenaten: The Heretic King, Princeton NJ (Princeton University Press) 1984.
  • Roehrig, H. et al. (eds): Hatshepsut: From Queen to Pharaoh, New York–New Haven–London (The Metropolitan Museum of New York and Yale University Press) 2005.
  • Rose, L.E.: Sun, Moon, and Sothis: A Study of Calendars and Calendar Reforms in Ancient Egypt, Richmond (Kronos Press / The Osiris Series II) 1999.
  • Sadek, c᾿el-A.F.: «Le plafond astronomique du Ramesseum», Memnonia 1, 1990-1991, 135-141.
  • Sales, H.: «Petosiris, the “Pharaoh”: A Usurper or a Restorer of the Order?», JHIE 3, 2020, 119-130.
  • Shaw, I.: Ancient Egypt. A very Short Introduction, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2004.
  • Steele, J.M.: The Circulation of Astronomical Knowledge in the Ancient World, Leiden (Brill) 2020.
  • Symons, S.: Ancient Egyptian Astronomy: Timekeeping and Cosmography in the New Kingdom, Leicester (University of Leicester) 1999.
  • Te Velde, H.: Seth, God of Confusion: A Study of his Role in Egyptian Mythology and Religion, Leiden (ProbAg 6) 2
  • Von Lieven, A.: Der Himmel uber Esna: Eine Fallstudie zur religiosen Astronomie in Agypten, Wiesbaden (O. Harrassowitz / AgAbh 64) 2000.
  • Von Lieven, A.: Grundriss des Laufs der Sterne: The Carlsberg Papyri 8, Copenhagen (Museum Tusculanum Press / The Carsten Niebuhr Institute of Near Eastern Studies 31)
  • = Erman, A. & Grapow, H.: Worterbuch der agyptischen Sprache I-V, Leipzig (J. Hinrichs) 1926-1931.
  • Winkler, A.: «Stellar Scientists: The Egyptian Temple Astrologers», Journal of Ancient Near Eastern History 8, 2021, 91-145.
More papers from this issue